Sushi by M

For New Yorkers with a discerning palate for exquisite Japanese cuisine, particularly those who cherish the intimate artistry of omakase, Sushi by M on the Upper East Side has emerged as a truly exceptional destination. This acclaimed sushi restaurant offers more than just a meal; it provides a curated culinary journey where each piece of sushi is a testament to freshness, flavor, and the chef's masterful skill. Patrons consistently rave about the "delicious, creative and amazing variety of fresh fish" that forms the backbone of their omakase experience. If you're looking to indulge in high-quality sushi that delights both the taste buds and the soul, Sushi by M is undoubtedly a must-visit spot in the heart of NYC.

Sushi by M is perfectly situated at 1575 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA, placing it in a prime and easily accessible location on Manhattan's vibrant Upper East Side. This central Second Avenue address ensures that the restaurant is a convenient destination for locals and visitors alike, leveraging New York City's comprehensive public transportation network. Numerous bus lines run directly along Second Avenue, and nearby subway stations provide efficient connections from various parts of the city. For those who prefer to walk or bike, Sushi by M is a visible and inviting establishment within this bustling urban environment. While street parking in this densely populated area can sometimes be challenging, the overall ease of access via public transit and its walkability make it a highly desirable dining spot. Its Upper East Side setting allows diners to enjoy a top-tier culinary experience within a dynamic neighborhood, perfect for combining a meal with other activities in the area.

Sushi by M specializes in delivering an immersive and personalized Japanese dining experience through its core service offerings:

• Omakase Dining: The centerpiece of Sushi by M's offerings is its renowned omakase experience, where guests entrust their meal to the sushi chef. The chef selects and prepares a sequence of meticulously crafted pieces, typically featuring seasonal and exceptionally fresh fish. This offers a unique and surprising culinary adventure.
• Value-Packed Omakase Menus: Sushi by M is highly praised for offering omakase options that provide "amazing value for the price." They typically offer multiple omakase tiers, allowing guests to choose an experience that fits their preference and budget. For example, customers have raved about a $100 Omakase option, and a $69 option is also mentioned, providing different course counts and selections.
• Dine-In Service: Guests enjoy their omakase meal within an intimate and welcoming setting. The ambiance is described as "light and bright," with a focus on a "sleek and minimalistic" yet "relaxed, intimate vibe." There are both sushi bar seats (highly recommended for the full omakase interaction) and table seating available.
• Attentive and Personalized Service: The staff, including specific chefs like Leo and Ben, and servers like Annie, are consistently praised for being "attentive," "personable," and "very sweet." They go above and beyond to make the dining experience special, including acknowledging birthdays.
• Takeout & Delivery (Limited): While the primary focus is the in-person omakase experience, it's worth checking if they offer select rolls or items for takeout or delivery through platforms like Uber Eats or Postmates, though the full omakase experience is best enjoyed on-site.
• Beverage Pairings: While not explicitly detailed, the mention of sake in reviews suggests a curated selection of beverages to complement the sushi, enhancing the overall meal.

Sushi by M has garnered a stellar reputation due to several distinguishing features that set it apart in New York City's competitive sushi scene:

• Exceptional Freshness and Quality of Fish: This is the most consistent and highly praised aspect. Customers repeatedly emphasize the "fresh fish" and "wonderful flavor," with fish often described as being "incredibly fresh" and portions being generous. The restaurant reportedly sources 90% of its fish from Toyosu Market in Japan.
• Creative and Delicious Omakase: The omakase is celebrated for being "delicious, creative, and had an amazing variety," with chefs curating a "phenomenal experience." Each piece is often a "delightful surprise," showcasing premium ingredients like sturgeon caviar, toro, A5 Wagyu, foie gras, and uni.
• Unbeatable Value for Omakase: For the quality and artistry presented, Sushi by M's omakase menus offer "amazing value for the price," making a high-end experience more accessible. Reviews specifically highlight $100 and $69 options as being "very worth it" and providing a "great price for this Omakase."
• Personalized Chef Interaction: Dining at the sushi bar offers direct interaction with the chefs (like Leo and Ben), who are noted for being friendly, welcoming, and making the experience "very special," particularly for first-time omakase diners.
• Outstanding Service: Beyond the chefs, the service staff (e.g., Annie, Stella, Bebe) are consistently lauded for their attentiveness, personable nature, and going "above and beyond" to accommodate guests, even for large parties or special occasions like birthdays.
• Thoughtful Customization: Diners appreciate the ability to request "more/less rice, soy sauce, wasabi, etc.," allowing for a truly tailored dining experience.
• Unique and Inventive Add-ons: The menu features "unconventional add-on dishes" like "Big Mac by M" (a layering of Wagyu beef, Toro, California Uni, and Hokkaido Uni) and "Cheeseburger by M" (toasted Japanese cheesecake and Toro topped with Uni and Caviar), showcasing the chef's creativity.
• Clean and Appealing Ambiance: The restaurant's interior is described as "light and bright," "sleek and minimalistic," with a "relaxed, intimate vibe," providing a comfortable and visually pleasing setting. The bathrooms are also noted as "very clean."
• Post-Meal Recommendations: The staff often enhance the experience by offering thoughtful recommendations, such as suggesting nearby dessert spots like Anita next door, providing a perfect end to the night.

Sushi by M's core "promotion" is its consistently praised and competitively priced omakase experiences, particularly the $100 and $69 options, which customers find to be an "amazing value for the price" given the quality and variety of fresh fish. While the provided reviews do not detail specific rotating promotions like happy hours or seasonal discounts, the inherent value of their set omakase menus serves as a continuous draw for New Yorkers. The personalized touches, such as birthday surprises mentioned by customers, also add significant value to the overall dining experience. For any potential new menu items, special chef's tastings, or holiday offerings, New York locals are always encouraged to check Sushi by M's official website or call them directly at their listed phone number. Given their focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients, their offerings are naturally dynamic and always worth inquiring about for the most current and exciting options.

Connecting with Sushi by M to reserve your exceptional omakase experience is simple:

Address: 1575 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

Phone: (929) 685-2040 (Note: Review snippets suggest this number might be for texting only for reservations, so checking their website for booking instructions is advisable).

Given the intimate nature of an omakase experience and its popularity, making a reservation well in advance is highly recommended to secure your spot. Their website or a direct call will provide the most accurate and up-to-date information on availability and booking procedures.

Sushi by M on the Upper East Side is an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended destination for New Yorkers seeking an unparalleled sushi experience. Its prime 2nd Avenue location offers easy accessibility, making it a convenient choice for a spontaneous indulgence or a planned special occasion.

What truly sets Sushi by M apart and makes it ideal for locals is its ability to deliver a top-tier omakase experience that combines high quality with remarkable value. New Yorkers appreciate fresh ingredients, and the consistent praise for Sushi by M's "incredibly fresh fish" and generous portions underscores its commitment to excellence. The chefs' creativity and ability to curate a "phenomenal" and "fun" experience, coupled with the attentive and personable service from staff members like Leo, Ben, and Annie, create a welcoming and memorable atmosphere that keeps patrons returning.

Whether it's a first omakase experience for a loved one or a treat for yourself, the diverse omakase options provide flexibility, ensuring there’s an experience for various preferences and budgets. The intimate yet bright ambiance allows diners to fully immerse themselves in the culinary artistry, fostering a peaceful escape from the city's hustle. For New Yorkers who crave expertly prepared sushi, a unique dining adventure, and service that makes you feel truly special, Sushi by M is more than just a sushi restaurant—it's a beloved neighborhood gem that consistently delivers on its promise of an unforgettable meal.

Sushi by M

1575 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA