The Other Fish

For those of us in Pennsylvania who cherish the delicate art and vibrant flavors of Japanese cuisine, finding a truly exceptional spot is always a delight. In the charming city of Bethlehem, nestled conveniently near Main Street, lies a true culinary treasure: The Other Fish. This Japanese restaurant has quickly garnered a reputation among locals for its outstanding sushi, delicious appetizers, and a dining experience that feels both welcoming and consistently satisfying. It's the kind of place you discover and immediately want to tell all your friends about.

The Other Fish is much more than just a sushi restaurant; it’s a vibrant culinary destination offering an authentic and refined Japanese experience. Patrons consistently rave about the "phenomenal" quality of the sushi, a testament to the freshness of their ingredients and the skill of their chefs. Beyond the meticulously crafted rolls and sashimi, the menu features a tempting array of appetizers and other Japanese dishes, ensuring there's something to please every palate. Whether it's the savory spicy seafood soup, the intriguing black truffle tuna appetizer, or a variety of expertly prepared sushi rolls, The Other Fish aims to deliver a memorable meal every time.

What truly sets this spot apart, as highlighted by numerous local reviews, is the overall atmosphere and service. Described as "welcoming," with "attentive and positive staff," The Other Fish creates a delightful ambiance that enhances the dining experience. It's frequently called a "hidden gem," indicating its understated quality and loyal following among those in the know. This blend of exceptional food, friendly service, and a great vibe makes The Other Fish a standout choice for Japanese cuisine in Bethlehem.

The Other Fish is strategically located at 59 E Broad St, Bethlehem, PA 18018, USA, making it incredibly convenient for residents and visitors alike. Its proximity to Main Street, a bustling hub in historic Bethlehem, means it's easily accessible and often a perfect stop before or after exploring the area's shops, galleries, and attractions. This central location contributes significantly to its appeal as a local favorite.

While street parking in downtown Bethlehem can sometimes be a challenge, the location on E Broad Street generally provides good access for those arriving by car. The pedestrian-friendly nature of the downtown area also means it’s easily reachable on foot for many in the immediate vicinity. For those who prefer to enjoy their Japanese feast at home, The Other Fish understands the need for convenience. They offer both takeout and delivery services through popular platforms like Uber Eats and DoorDash, ensuring that their delicious sushi and appetizers are just a few clicks away. While one review wished for more outdoor seating, the restaurant does offer some patio seating, especially during warmer months, which adds to its charm and provides an enjoyable al fresco dining option.

The restaurant operates on the following schedule:

• Monday: Closed
• Tuesday - Thursday: 12:00 PM - 10:30 PM
• Friday: 12:00 PM - 10:30 PM
• Saturday: 11:00 AM - 10:30 PM
• Sunday: 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM

• Dine-In Service: Enjoy a fantastic dining experience in a welcoming ambiance with attentive staff, perfect for a casual meal or a special occasion.
• Takeout: Conveniently order your favorite sushi rolls, appetizers, and other dishes for pickup, allowing you to enjoy The Other Fish's flavors in the comfort of your home.
• Delivery: The Other Fish partners with popular delivery platforms such as Uber Eats and DoorDash, offering seamless delivery right to your doorstep within their service area.
• Extensive Sushi and Sashimi Menu: A wide array of fresh sushi and sashimi, including traditional rolls (e.g., Spicy Tuna, California Roll, Salmon Roll), "Hot New Rolls" (e.g., Godzilla Roll, The Snow Goose Roll, Funky Monkey Roll), and "Dancina Fish Favorites Rolls" (e.g., Andretti Roll, Tracy Roll, Belletti Roll).
• Appetizers: A diverse selection of starters like spicy seafood soup, inari with spicy tuna and shrimp tempura, black truffle tuna appetizer, Harumaki (Japanese vegetable spring roll), Shumai (steamed shrimp dumpling), Gyoza (pan-fried pork dumplings), Edamame, and more.
• Nigiri and Sashimi: Individual pieces of fresh fish like Tuna, Salmon, Scallops, White Tuna, Eel, and more.
• Vegetarian Options: A variety of rolls and dishes featuring fruits and vegetables such as Cucumber, Spicy Avocado, Sweet Potato Tempura, Shiitake, Asparagus, and Mixed Veggie rolls.
• Lunch Specials: During lunch hours (typically Tuesday through Saturday, 11:45 AM to 3:00 PM), special offers like "Any 2 Rolls" or "Any 3 Rolls" deals are available, along with Hibachi Lunch and Lunch Bento Boxes.

• Phenomenal Sushi Quality: The most consistent praise is for the exceptional quality and freshness of their sushi, with many customers describing it as "fantastic" and "phenomenal," leaving them "wanting more."
• Delicious and Diverse Menu: Beyond sushi, the menu is extensive, offering a variety of tantalizing appetizers like the black truffle tuna appetizer and noodle-wrapped shrimp, as well as a wide selection of unique and creative sushi rolls.
• Welcoming Ambiance: Customers frequently comment on the restaurant's great "vibe," describing it as welcoming and providing a comfortable dining experience.
• Attentive and Positive Staff: The service is consistently highlighted as fast, attentive, and friendly, contributing significantly to a positive overall impression.
• Hidden Gem Status: Many locals consider The Other Fish a "hidden gem" near Main Street, implying a high-quality establishment that's beloved by those who discover it.
• Convenient Location in Historic Bethlehem: Its spot on E Broad Street makes it easily accessible for downtown exploration and dining.
• Outdoor Seating Option: While some may desire more, the presence of outdoor seating provides an appealing option for al fresco dining during pleasant weather.
• Consistency: Regular patrons note that the food and service quality remain consistently high across multiple visits, ensuring a reliable and enjoyable experience.

While specific daily or weekly promotions are not always explicitly advertised on public review sites, The Other Fish has been known to offer special menus for holidays, such as a reservation-only, multi-course Valentine's Day dinner for couples, as seen in past years. This suggests they curate unique culinary experiences for special occasions. It is highly recommended for locals to check The Other Fish's official website or their social media channels for the most up-to-date information on any ongoing promotions, seasonal specials, or holiday menus. You might also find special deals or discounts if you order through their third-party delivery partners like Uber Eats or DoorDash, which occasionally run platform-wide promotions that could apply. For those looking for lunch deals, their weekday "Any 2 Rolls" or "Any 3 Rolls" lunch specials are a consistent offering that provides excellent value.

To experience the highly-rated Japanese cuisine at The Other Fish, make a reservation, or place an order for pickup or delivery, you can use the following contact details:

Address: 59 E Broad St, Bethlehem, PA 18018, USA

Phone: (484) 821-1370

Mobile Phone: +1 484-821-1370

It's always advisable to call ahead, especially during peak dining hours or for larger groups, to confirm seating availability or place your takeout order efficiently.

For anyone in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, who appreciates top-tier Japanese cuisine, The Other Fish is an undeniable standout. Its prime location on E Broad Street, just a stone's throw from Main Street, makes it incredibly accessible for a casual lunch, a delightful dinner, or a quick takeout order after exploring downtown. This convenience, coupled with flexible hours including weekend brunch, ensures that it fits seamlessly into any local's schedule.

The core appeal for locals lies in the consistently phenomenal quality of their sushi and the delicious variety of their menu. From the rave reviews about their inventive rolls like the "Snow Goose" and "Tracy" to the tempting appetizers such as the black truffle tuna, The Other Fish consistently delivers on flavor and freshness. Beyond the food, the welcoming ambiance and the attentive, positive staff create a dining experience that feels truly special. It's a place where you're not just eating; you're enjoying a fantastic vibe that makes you want to return. Whether you're a long-time sushi aficionado or simply looking for a great meal in a friendly setting, The Other Fish is a true hidden gem that continually impresses its Bethlehem patrons, making it a perfect fit for the local community's culinary desires.

The Other Fish

59 E Broad St, Bethlehem, PA 18018, USA