Sushi Sushi: Harlem's Trusted Spot for Fresh, Affordable Sushi and Great Service

Sushi Sushi Introduce

sushi in harlem

Hey New Yorkers! Finding a reliable, delicious, and genuinely good value sushi spot in our vast city can sometimes feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. But for those of us in Harlem and the surrounding Upper Manhattan neighborhoods, there's a strong contender that's quickly becoming a local staple: Sushi Sushi. This isn't about ultra-high-end omakase; it's about delivering consistent quality, fresh flavors, and excellent service that keeps locals coming back for more.

Sushi Sushi has garnered a reputation as a pleasant surprise in the Harlem sushi scene. Customers often highlight the freshness and taste, with one reviewer stating they were "very pleasantly surprised" and that "everything tasted fresh and really good," acknowledging that "Sushi in Harlem can be risky." This underscores the consistent quality Sushi Sushi aims to deliver. A significant draw for regulars is the "great lunch special," which offers excellent value without compromising on taste.

What truly sets Sushi Sushi apart, however, is their commitment to customer satisfaction. One telling review recounts an initial order that "wasn’t that good," but upon returning it, "they made me a new order. It was really nice and appreciated that they reconciled the meal." This willingness to go above and beyond to ensure a positive experience is rare and highly valued, turning a potentially negative encounter into a loyal customer, as the reviewer later stated, "I’ve become a regular." Combined with "good music" and "good service," Sushi Sushi offers a welcoming and reliable spot for your sushi cravings.

Location and Accessibility

Sushi Sushi is conveniently located at 1504 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA. This address places it squarely in the vibrant and easily accessible Hamilton Heights neighborhood of Upper Manhattan, just a stone's throw from the dynamic pulse of Broadway. Amsterdam Avenue is a well-known thoroughfare, making the restaurant a recognizable and convenient destination for both local residents and those navigating the area.

For New Yorkers who rely on public transportation, Sushi Sushi's location offers excellent connectivity. It's typically within comfortable walking distance of several major subway lines. The 1 train, with stops at 157th Street and 145th Street, provides direct access. Additionally, the A, B, C, and D express and local trains at 145th Street offer further connectivity from various parts of Manhattan and other boroughs. While finding street parking in bustling New York City can always be a challenge, the robust public transit options ensure that visiting Sushi Sushi for a quick bite or a satisfying meal is a hassle-free experience.

Services Offered

Sushi Sushi provides a comprehensive range of services designed to meet the diverse needs of its New York clientele:

Dine-In Experience: The restaurant offers a casual and comfortable setting for those who wish to enjoy their meal on-site. While described as a "little sushi spot," it provides a welcoming atmosphere, complemented by "good music" for a pleasant dining experience.
Takeout: A popular choice for many locals, Sushi Sushi offers efficient takeout services. You can easily place your order by phone for quick and convenient pickup, perfect for grabbing a fresh meal on the go.
Delivery: Sushi Sushi partners with major third-party food delivery platforms such as Uber Eats, Grubhub, and Seamless. This allows customers to enjoy their fresh sushi and other Japanese dishes from the comfort of their homes or offices, extending their reach across Harlem and beyond. Free delivery is often available with certain memberships on these platforms.
Extensive Menu: The menu features a wide array of options beyond just sushi rolls. They offer traditional rolls, signature rolls (like Dinosaur Roll, Dragon Roll, Rainbow Roll, and Awesome Roll), nigiri, sashimi, and various combo platters. Beyond sushi, the menu includes appetizers (such as Edamame, Seaweed Salad, Spicy Tuna Jalapeno Poppers, Shrimp Shumai, and various Tartares), Sashimi Rice Bowls, and Teriyaki Rice Bowls (with choices of Salmon, Fluke, Tuna, Striped Bass, and Three Fish Medley). They also cater to different dietary preferences with vegetarian and vegan options.
Catering Services: For larger gatherings or events, Sushi Sushi offers catering party trays, including Traditional Roll Party Trays, Signature Roll Party Trays, and Sushi Party Trays, making it convenient to bring their fresh offerings to your celebration.

Features / Highlights

Sushi Sushi stands out in the competitive New York City dining scene with several key features and highlights:

Consistently Fresh and Good-Tasting Sushi: A recurring theme in customer reviews is the freshness and quality of the sushi. Despite being a casual spot, patrons consistently find that "everything tasted fresh and really good," dispelling any "risky" notions about sushi in the area.
Exceptional Value on Lunch Specials: The "great lunch special" is a significant draw, offering affordable options like "2 Traditional Rolls + Miso Soup" for $9.95 and "3 Traditional Rolls + Miso Soup" for $14.95. These deals provide excellent value for a satisfying midday meal in NYC.
Commitment to Customer Satisfaction: A standout feature is their willingness to rectify issues. The story of replacing an unsatisfactory order highlights their dedication to ensuring customers are happy, fostering trust and loyalty. This proactive approach to "reconcile the meal" is highly appreciated by patrons.
Friendly and Good Service: Reviewers consistently praise the "good service" and the welcoming nature of the staff, which contributes to a positive dining experience whether you're dining in or picking up an order.
Diverse Menu with Specialty Rolls: Beyond traditional options, Sushi Sushi offers an extensive selection of signature rolls (e.g., Spicy Delight Roll, The Manhattan, Tempura Combo, Salmon Extreme, Tuna Extreme, Eel Extreme) and other Japanese dishes, ensuring there's something to appeal to every taste and preference.
Good Ambiance (Music): While described as a "little" spot, the presence of "good music" contributes to a pleasant and enjoyable atmosphere, making it a comfortable place for a quick meal.

Promotions or Special Offers

Sushi Sushi is well-regarded for its value-driven promotions, making it a fantastic choice for New Yorkers looking for quality sushi that's also budget-friendly:

Lunch Specials: A major highlight, their lunch specials are available daily from 11:30 AM to 4:00 PM. These include:
- 2 Traditional Rolls + Miso Soup for $9.95: An excellent deal for a quick and satisfying lunch.
- 3 Traditional Rolls + Miso Soup for $14.95: Providing even more variety and value.
These specials are often cited by customers as a reason they "love it!" and have "become a regular."
Dinner Specials: Available from 5:00 PM to 10:00 PM, these offers provide more comprehensive meal options:
- 2 Traditional Rolls + Soup + 2 pcs Sushi for $20.20
- Signature Roll + Traditional Roll + Soup + 2 pcs Sushi for $24.95
They also feature "Extreme" combos (e.g., Salmon Extreme, Tuna Extreme, Eel Extreme) and Sushi Box options that include soup or salad.
Catering Party Trays: While not a daily special, their catering options (e.g., Traditional Roll Party Tray, Signature Roll Party Tray) offer cost-effective solutions for feeding groups, perfect for local gatherings or office events.
Exclusive Fish Offerings: They periodically offer exclusive fish like Black Sea Bass or American Red Snapper as limited-time specials, providing unique tasting opportunities.

For the most current information on their daily specials, it's always best to check their website, online ordering platforms (like Seamless or Grubhub), or call them directly.

Contact Information

Ready to discover your new favorite sushi spot in Harlem? Here’s how you can get in touch with Sushi Sushi:

Address: 1504 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

Phone: (212) 866-7876

Feel free to call for takeout orders, delivery inquiries, or to learn more about their extensive menu and daily specials.

Conclusion: Why Sushi Sushi is Suitable for Locals

For New Yorkers, especially those in the vibrant Harlem and Hamilton Heights neighborhoods, Sushi Sushi is an exceptionally suitable and highly recommended local dining choice. Its consistent delivery of "fresh and really good" sushi, coupled with truly "great lunch specials" and dinner deals, directly addresses the local desire for both quality and affordability in a city where dining costs can add up quickly. It offers a practical and delicious solution for everyday sushi cravings.

What truly elevates Sushi Sushi beyond just another sushi spot is its unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction. The willingness to "reconcile the meal" if an order isn't perfect speaks volumes about their dedication to their patrons, fostering a sense of trust and loyalty that is invaluable in a local business. This, combined with "good service" and a pleasant atmosphere, makes it a welcoming place where customers feel valued and become "regulars."

Whether you're grabbing a quick, affordable lunch, enjoying a relaxed dinner, or ordering delivery for a cozy night in, Sushi Sushi seamlessly integrates into the New York lifestyle. It provides a reliable, high-quality, and friendly option for Japanese cuisine that consistently exceeds expectations, making it a true gem for the Upper Manhattan community.

Sushi Sushi Vibe

Appetizers
Miso Soup US$3.95
Miso Soup - it's also gluten free.
Green Salad US$3.95
Green Salad - Lettuce, tomato, cucumbers and carrot ginger dressing
Edamame US$6.95
Veggitizer US$7.95
Sweet potato, broccoli, and asparagus tempura, side of ponzu sauce
Seaweed Salad US$6.95
Sashimi App US$9.95
Salmon Tartare US$9.95
Tuna Tartare US$10.95
Shrimp Shumai US$6.95
Shrimp Dumplings Fried or Steamed
Tempuratizer US$7.95
Shrimp Tempura, Kani crab Tempura with a side of ponzu sauce
Salmon Mango Salad US$9.95
Diced salmon and mango on a bed of lettuce, avocados, drizzled with spicy and spicy mango sauce
Crabby Salad US$6.95
Kani, cucumber, tobiko, tempura flakes, mildly spicy sauce
Bowl of Sushi Rice White/Brown US$3.95
Spicy Salmon Tartare US$9.95
Spicy salmon tartare with avocado, mango, spicy mayo, tobiko and scallion.
Spicy Tuna Jalapeno Poppers US$7.95
Spicy tuna jalapeno poppers with tobiko and scallion.

Traditional Rolls
Brown Rice + 1.25 US$1.25
Substitute Brown Rice + 1
Avocado Asparagus Tempura Cucumber Roll US$6.95
Avocado, asparagus tempura, cucumber roll
Cucumber Roll US$6.95
Cucumber Roll
Avocado Roll US$6.95
Avocado Roll
Cucumber Avocado Roll US$6.95
Jalapeno Avocado Mango Roll US$6.95
Jalapeno Avocado Mango Roll
Cucumber Mango Cream Cheese Roll US$6.95
Cucumber, mango, cream cheese roll
Mango Avocado Roll US$6.95
Shiitake Mushroom Tempura Avocado Roll US$6.95
Shiitake Mushroom Tempura Avocado Sushi Roll
Tofu Inari Roll US$6.95
Tofu inari roll
Sweet Potato Tempura Roll US$6.95
Drizzled with eel sauce
California Roll US$6.95
crab and avocado
Spicy Salmon Roll US$6.95
Spicy salmon roll
Eel Avocado Roll US$6.95
Eel Avocado Roll
Eel Cucumber Roll US$6.95
Salmon Skin Roll US$6.95
Salmon skin, cucumber drizzled with eel sauce.
Tuna Mango Roll US$6.95
Tuna Mango Roll
Tuna Avocado Roll US$6.95
Tuna avocado roll
Yellowtail Jalapeno Roll US$6.95
Yellowtail (Hamachi) jalapeno roll.
Yellowtail Scallion Roll US$6.95
Hamachi Scallion Roll.
Spicy Yellowtail Roll US$6.95
Spicy Yellowtail/Hamachi Roll
Spicy Shrimp Avocado Roll US$6.95
Spicy shrimp avocado roll.
Spicy Tuna Roll US$6.95
Spicy tuna roll
Boston Roll US$6.95
Shrimp, lettuce, cucumber
Shrimp Tempura Roll US$6.95
Shrimp tempura, cucumber, avocado drizzled with eel sauce
Salmon Cucumber Cream Cheese Roll US$6.95
Salmon Cucumber Cream Cheese Roll
Spicy Crab Roll US$6.95
Spicy crab roll
Salmon Avocado Roll US$6.95
Salmon avocado roll
Salmon Mango Roll US$6.95
Salmon Mango Roll
Philadelphia Roll US$6.95
Smoked salmon, Philadelphia cream cheese
Tuna Roll US$6.95
Salmon Roll US$6.95
Salmon roll
Cucumber Tempura Oshinko Roll US$6.95
Cucumber Tempura Oshinko Roll
Hokkaido Scallop Avocado Roll US$6.95
Wild Japanese Hokkaido Scallop Avocado Roll
Baked Alaska Roll US$6.95
Cooked salmon, cucumber drizzled with eel sauce.

Signature Rolls
Brown rice + 1.25 US$1.25
Substitute brown rice + 1
Spicy Delight Roll US$14.95
Spicy tuna, avocado topped with spicy salmon and tobiko, drizzled with Sushi Sushi's spicy mayo.
Rainbow Roll US$14.95
Crab, avocado topped with tuna, fluke, striped bass and salmon.
Veggie Delight Roll US$14.95
Shiitake mushroom tempura, cucumber topped with avocado and sweet potato tempura drizzled with spicy mango sauce
The Park Roll US$14.95
Spicy Yellowtail, cucumber, topped with fluke/striped bass and avocado, drizzled with mango sauce
Sushi Sushi Roll US$14.95
Spicy crab, avocado topped with salmon, fluke/striped bass, drizzled with mango miso sauce
Yellowtaxi Roll US$14.95
Shrimp tempura, mango topped with spicy yellowtail, tobiko and jalapenos, drizzled with spicy sauce
Senaka Roll US$14.95
Spicy salmon, cucumber topped with tuna, avocado drizzled with ume miso sauce
Bagel with Lox Roll US$14.95
Smoked Salmon, cream cheese topped with salmon, avocado, scallion drizzled with honey wasabi mayo.
Dinosaur Roll US$14.95
Shrimp tempura, cucumber topped with eel and avocado, drizzled with eel sauce
Awesome Roll US$14.95
Spicy tuna, cucumber topped with salmon, avocado, drizzled with miso sauce
Dragon Roll US$14.95
Crab, avocado topped with eel, avocado drizzled with eel sauce
Spider Roll US$14.95
Soft shell crab, avocado, cucumber, drizzled with eel sauce
Veggie Lover Roll US$14.95
Sweet potato tempura, mango topped with avocado, drizzled with Sushi Sushi's spicy mayo
Tuna Lover Roll US$14.95
una, yellowtail, avocado topped with spicy tuna, drizzled with Sushi Sushi's spicy mayo
Seafood Lover Roll US$14.95
Shrimp tempura, cucumber topped with spicy crab and avocado, drizzled with spicy eel sauce
Golden Tiger Roll US$14.95
Salmon, avocado topped with mango, tobiko drizzled with spicy mango sauce
Shrimp Lover Roll US$14.95
Shrimp tempura, cucumber topped with sushi shrimp, avocado drizzled with spicy eel sauce
Salmon Lover Roll US$14.95
Salmon, mango topped with spicy salmon, drizzled with honey wasabi mayo
Dancing Shrimp Roll US$14.95
Shrimp tempura cucumber inside topped with spicy tuna, green tobiko drizzled with spicy eel sauce.

Sushi and Sashimi
Brown rice +.5 US$0.50
Substitute brown rice + .5
Salmon US$2.50
Tuna US$2.50
Fluke US$2.50
Fluke sushi/sashimi
Striped Bass US$2.50
Striped Bass sushi/sashimi
Sweet Potato US$2.50
Sweet potato tempura sushi/sashimi
Shiitake Mushroom US$2.50
Shiitake mushroom tempura sushi/sashimi
Kani Crab US$2.50
Inari US$2.50
Yellowtail US$2.50
Tobiko US$2.50
Shrimp US$2.50
Eel US$2.50
Avocado US$2.50
Avocado sushi/sashimi
Cucumber US$2.50
Cucumber sushi/sashimi
Shrimp Tempura US$2.50
Smoked Salmon US$2.50

Specials
Spicy Special US$21.95
Spicy Tuna Avocado Roll, Spicy Salmon Avocado Roll and Spicy Crab Avocado Roll. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
The Manhattan US$29.95
Spicy Delight Roll, Salmon Avocado Roll and Shrimp Tempura roll. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
Veggie Extreme US$32.95
Veggie Lover Roll, Veggie Delight Roll and Avocado Roll. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
Tempura Combo US$32.95
Spider Roll, Dinosaur Roll and Shrimp Tempura Roll. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
Salmon Extreme US$32.95
Salmon Mango Avocado Salad, Salmon Lover Roll, Spicy Salmon Roll and Salmon Sushi. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
Tuna Extreme US$32.95
Tuna Tartare, Tuna Lover Roll, Spicy Tuna Roll and Tuna Sushi. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
Eel Extreme US$32.95
Eel Rice Bowl, Eel Avocado and Eel Sushi. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.

Sushi Boxes
Sushi Deluxe + Any Roll US$32.95
2 Tuna, 2 Salmon, Yellowtail, Fluke, Striped Bass, Shrimp, Eel. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
TriColored Sushi Box + Traditional Roll US$32.95
3 Tuna, 3 Salmon, 3 Yellowtail. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
Sushi and Sashimi for 1 + Traditional Roll US$32.95
Salmon, Striped Bass, Tuna, Kani Crab Sushi, 2 Tuna, 2 Salmon, Fluke, Yellowtail, Shrimp, Eel Sashimi. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
Sashimi Deluxe + Traditional Roll US$32.95
3 Salmon, 2 Tuna, 2 Fluke, 2 Striped Bass, 1 Kani Crab, 1 Shrimp, 1 Eel, 1 Yellowtail. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.
Sushi and Sashimi for 2 + Traditional Roll + Signature Roll US$58.00
8 pcs Sushi/15 pcs Sashimi. Served with Miso Soup or Green Salad.

Sashimi Rice Bowls
Comes with: US$0.00
All come with sliced avocado, cucumber, and mango (1) Choice: Miso Soup or Green Salad (2) Choice of Rice: White Rice or Brown Rice (3) Choice of sauce: Sushi Sushi’s Spicy Mayo Mango sauce Eel sauce Spicy mango sauce Spicy eel sauce Honey wasabi mayo Ume miso sauce
Salmon US$19.95
Salmon Sashimi Rice Bowl
Chef Deluxe US$19.95
2 Salmon, 2 Tuna, 2 Yellowtail, 2 Fluke/Striped Bass
Eel US$19.95
Shrimp Tempura US$19.95
Tofu & Inari US$19.95
Salmon & Tuna US$19.95
Salmon and Tuna Sashimi Rice Bowl

Teriyaki Rice Bowl
Comes with US$0.00
All come with sliced avocado and cucumber (1) Choice: Miso Soup or Green Salad (2) Choice of Rice: White Rice or Brown Rice
Salmon US$21.95
Fluke US$21.95
Tuna US$21.95
Striped Bass US$21.95
Shrimp US$21.95
3 Fish Medley US$21.95
Salmon & Tuna & Fluke

Signature Sauces
12oz Carrot Ginger Dressing US$4.99
12oz Sushi Sushi’s Spicy mayo US$8.99
Honey Wasabi Mayo US$1.25
Spicy Eel Sauce US$1.25
Sushi Sushi's Spicy Mayo US$1.25
Ume Miso Sauce US$1.25
Mango Sauce US$1.25
Eel Sauce US$1.25
Spicy Mango Sauce US$1.25
Sweet Jalapeno Sauce US$1.25

Dessert
Banana Nutella w/ Strawberries Roll US$5.50
Banana & Nutella on sweetened rice topped with strawberries
PB&J Roll US$5.50
Peanut butter & jelly on white bread, no crust, rolled up
Twinkies Tempura US$5.50
Twinkies are Back! 2 Twinkies Tempurared

Sushi Grade Fish
Salmon (Scottish)(1/2 lb) US$13.50
Fluke (1/2lb) US$12.00
Yellowtail (1/2lb) US$19.00
Smoked Salmon (1/2lb) US$10.00
Striped Bass (1/2lb) US$12.00
Shrimp (Sushi)(1/2lb) US$12.00
Tuna (1/2lb) US$19.00
Eel (1/2lb) US$19.00
Kani Crab (1/2lb) US$11.00
Avocado (ea) US$4.00

Sushi Sushi Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Kerbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Wheelchair-accessible car park

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Comfort food
Happy-hour food
Healthy options
Late-night food
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Toilet
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Trendy

Crowd
Family friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safe space

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Sushi Sushi Photos

Sushi Sushi Location

Sushi Sushi

New York New York County New York Amsterdam Avenue

1504 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10031, USA

Sushi Sushi Reviews

Found this little sushi spot in Harlem and decided to run in for a quick meal and was very pleasantly surprised. Sushi in Harlem can be risky, but everything tasted fresh and really good. The lunch special was a great price. The music was good and so was the service. Will definitely go back.
May 16 · Brian A
The original order of sushi I got wasn’t that good so I brought it back and they made me a new order. It was really nice and appreciated that they reconciled the meal.Update: I’ve become a regular.Great lunch specials. Love it!
January 04 · Asana Rose
Don’t get sushi ever anymore from this place. I bought couple times they’re really over charge. Last time I’ve ordered spicy tuna roll, Philadelphia roll, and salmon teriyaki, I’ve paid over $50 and I wasn’t sure what I paid for. The other day same thing happened whoever white guy sales they not showing receipts unless you ask for. Place dirty, takes too long, salesman rude. I felt like I owe them something. I would never stop by this place again ever in my life. I’m really disappointed. Don’t go ever
April 14 · sher aa
food was good! little atmosphere. house music playing.. more like a fast food spot where you get your food and sit. food was delicious tho, they must get a lot of takeout orders. would go back again
October 04 · Gabriela Reyes
spicy salmon was extremely salty. shrimp tempura and scallop roll were good. nice restaurant vibes. 16 for 3 roll plus soup
February 11 · Thanjila Thahsin